jump to navigation

Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone, ch. 1-5 Monday, June 4, 2007

Posted by ladyandrea in harry potter, Lady Andrea, summer of awesomeness, unhealthy obsessions.
trackback

Just real quick: there are a number of people reading the series for the first time for the express purpose of participating in discussion here. For me, the best aspects of my first time reading each book were the twists and turns. So, let’s try to keep spoilers to a minimum and stick to discussing what we’ve “read” for each day, so that newbies can get the most out of their reading. If we need to move discussion that includes spoilers to another thread, I’ll look into that when/if we get there. Thanks!

Here we go, the book that started it all. The Boy Who Lived starts us off with a glimpse into the lives of the Dursley family. Dudley, a baby, is having a tantrum and Vernon heads off to work, noticing a cat that “gives him a stern look.” Heh. Basically, it’s just a very weird day for Vernon. A cat appears to be reading a map, grown men are wearing cloaks and there are reports of “showers of owls” on the news. The owls are not what they seem, Vernon.

Finally, we get our first encounter with Dumbledore. I have to say, I wish the chapter had started at this point, with Dumbledore’s arrival. There is a perfect scene in Chapter 2 to establish the unpleasantness of the Dursleys and McGonagall is soon to inform Dumbledore about the weird happenings all day long. Therefore, I think a much more dramatic start would’ve been Dumbledore’s sudden appearance on Privet Drive. But I digress….

The entrance of Dumbledore is just wonderful: “He was tall, thin, and very old, judging by the silver of his hair and beard, which were long enough to tuck into his belt. He was wearing long robes, a purple cloak that swept the ground, and high-heeled, buckled boots. His blue eyes were light, bright, and sparkling behind half-moon spectacles and his nose was very long and crooked, as though it had been broken at least twice. This man’s name was Albus Dumbledore.” Of course it’s been broken at least twice. Dumbledore kicks ass and takes names, bitches.

Dumbledore sits down next to the cat that was previously reading a map and she changes back into Professor McGonagall. They have a nice bit of exposition about Voldemort’s downfall, Lily and James Potter’s deaths, how Dumbledore is the only wizard Voldemort ever feared and how little baby Harry Potter survived the attack, left with a lightning-bolt shaped scar on his forehead. You’d think McGonagall would already know what’s up, but if Dumbledore dispatched her to the Dursleys at the start of the day, she may not have heard. I’ll allow it. I’ll not be so judicious later in the series with exposition recaps I find annoying.

Anyway, Hagrid arrives with baby Harry, having borrowed Sirius Black’s flying motorbike. Dumbledore tells Hagrid and McGonagall that they’re leaving Harry with his relatives so that he grows up away from the limelight. I think this is a huge part in what makes Harry so great. The three adults say goodbye and they leave him on the doorstep. They do not ding-ding ditch, though I like the idea of Hagrid trying to run off into the night after ringing the doorbell.

The Vanishing Glass opens with a perfect scene to showcase the nastiness of the Dursleys. It is now 10 years later and Harry sleeps in a cupboard and gets ordered around to make breakfast by his Aunt Petunia. It’s Dudley’s 11th birthday and he gets ready to throw a right little tantrum when he only has 37 presents, when he got 38 last year. Uh, I don’t think I’ve gotten 38 birthday presents in my entire life, pukestain.

This scene also gets my first real laugh. Rowling does have a good sense of humor and I love, “Aunt Petunia often said that Dudley looked like a baby angel – Harry often said that Dudley looked like a pig in a wig.” Hee, pigs are funny. Pigs dressed like people are even funnier. Just ask Suzanne Sugarbaker.

Due to the neighbor, Mrs. Figg, having broken her leg, she cannot babysit Harry and he gets to go along to the Zoo for Dudley’s birthday. He gets to eat Dudley’s leftover ice cream and it’s just so sad how delighted that makes Harry. In the Reptile House (which you could not pay me to go into, snakes are terrifying), a giant boa constrictor winks at Harry and communicates with him via nodding and pointing his tail. When Harry makes the glass on the cage vanish, he swears he hears the snake say, “Thankssss, amigo” on its way out.

We fade out on Harry, lying in bed in his cupboard, thinking about his parents’ death in a car crash and all the weird people on the street who wave or bow to him all the time.

The Letters from No One kicks off with Harry and Dudley’s finally diverging in their scholarly paths (you don’t know the half of it, Harry!) as Harry will go to public school in the fall and Dudley will start a private school, Smeltings. Apparently a giant walking stick is part of the Smeltings uniform and I now wish I had attended a school like that, just so I had stick to whack people with. Maybe I’ll just get one. Call it Bertha the Beatin’ Stick and start bringing it with me to class. That would certainly liven Patent Law right the hell up.

Harry is ordered to go get the mail and finds a letter addressed to H. Potter, Cupboard Under the Stairs (hee), “his heart twanging like a giant elastic band.” Awwww. Vernon makes a joke about checking for letter bombs. We could only be so lucky, Porky. When he sees Harry has a letter, he snatches it away and kicks both Harry and Dudley out of the kitchen. He and Petunia say they’ve sworn to stamp out that dangerous nonsense and while I understand their fear and bigotry about magic, I also feel like they’d be jumping for joy at sending Harry away for 10 months.

At the paranoia of the letter being addressed to Harry’s cupboard, the Dursleys give Harry the extra bedroom upstairs, which is SO GENEROUS of them. You know, having a fourth bedroom and getting your nephew out of the cupboard he’s slept in for 10 years and all. Nice. Also, the bedroom houses Dudley’s relics and my favorite is an air rifle with a bent barrel from when he sat on it. I am suddenly picturing Dudley like this. Harry laments “yesterday he’d have given anything to be up here. Today he’d rather be back in his cupboard with that letter than up here without it.” Awwww.

This chapter has great visuals. Dudley’s tantrum when he can’t get his EXTRA bedroom back, Uncle Vernon wrestling Dudley to the ground for another letter that arrives for Harry, while Harry grabs Vernon around the neck (kind of like the troll!). 24 letters arriving rolled up inside two dozen eggs. Great stuff.

Finally, Vernon snaps and loads everyone up in the car. They drive around all day, randomly. “By nightfall, Dudley was howling. He’d never had such a bad day in his life. He was hungry, he’d missed five television programs he’d wanted to see, and he’d never gone so long without blowing up an alien on his computer.” Substitute “blowing up an alien” to “looking at porn” and I totally hear ya, Dudley.

In the morning, they have a breakfast of cold tinned tomatoes on toast. That sounds like the most disgusting thing I could have for breakfast, after pieces of shit. Seriously, ew. What is with the British and food? Also, we learn that Harry got a coat hanger and a pair of old socks for his birthday one year from the Dursleys. Why would they even bother to give him that stuff? I guess maybe that’s a better way to rub it in than giving him nothing, so congratulations Dursleys.

Vernon decides they are going to hide from the onslaught of letters by heading to a tiny shack on an island. “A toothless old man came ambling up to them, pointing, with a rather wicked grin, at an old rowboat bobbing in the iron-gray water below them.” He then said, “The bridge might get washed out and should a mysterious voice play a blackmail record and then little Indian statues start disappearing, don’t pay any attention.”

At night, huddled on the floor, Harry realizes his birthday is coming up at midnight. In the movie, I love the detail where he draws himself a birthday cake in the dirt floor. That is so sad and adorable. Just as the clock strikes midnight, there’s a great bang on the door! DUN DUN DUN!

In Keeper of the Keys, Hagrid arrives and we get a load of exposition about Harry’s parents and Voldemort’s reign of terror. It’s nice because it fits the confines of the story, Harry not knowing anything and all. I’ll allow it. I’m not going to summarize it all here; we get plenty of that in each book. I do like Hagrid’s passing comment, “Yeh look a lot like your dad, but yeh’ve got yer mom’s eyes.” The first of many.

Also, at Hagrid’s surprise and shock at how little Harry knows, Harry responds, “I know some things. I can, you know, do math and stuff.” Heh heh. That’s totally going to be my stock answer at work from now on.

Vernon insults Dumbledore and Hagrid goes ballistic, which is a nice running theme throughout the books. Hagrid’s loyalty to Dumbledore is a wonderful relationship. Hagrid tries to turn Dudley into a pig (hee, pigs are funny), but only succeeds in making him sprout a tail. That’ll do, Hagrid, that’ll do.

In the morning, Hagrid and Harry set off for Diagon Alley (also the chapter name) to buy Harry’s school supplies. Harry learns on the way about the wizarding money and that it is kept in Gringotts Bank, which is run by goblins. He also learns about the Ministry of Magic as the governing body of wizards and how the Minister of Magic, Cornelius Fudge, is always pestering Dumbledore with owls for advice.

After riding the tube, Harry and Hagrid “climb a broken-down escalator.” That’s the beauty of escalators. They can never break. They can only become stairs. Hee. Inside the Leaky Cauldron pub, everybody wants to shake Harry’s hand, it’s very sweet. He meets Professor Quirrell, the Defense Against the Dark Arts teacher from Hogwarts, and Hagrid tells Harry Quirrell spent a year in the Black Forest area and didn’t come back quite right. Hmmmmm, spooky. Those Grimm Fairy Tale creatures are not to be trifled with.

Harry and Hagrid take a trip to the bank and get some money for Harry, who appears to have a small fortune tucked away for him. That’s awfully sweet. If your parents are gonna get blowed up, it’s nice if they leave you some change. Also, Hagrid gets a special unnamed object out of vault #713 for Dumbledore. *cocks eyebrow*

Harry gets his robes and some books and Hagrid buys him a snowy owl for his birthday. Harry can’t “stop stammering his thanks.” Awwwww, a real birthday present. Hagrid also tells Harry about the four Hogwarts houses, saying “There’s not a single witch or wizard who went bad who wasn’t in Slytherin.” To which I say: boooooo, JK Rowling. I’ve got more to say about this, but it’s kind of spoilery, so I’ll wait for a later date. But my soapbox is at the ready.

We then get one of my favorite scenes: Harry’s wand purchase. Ollivander’s is the place for wands and Harry says, “For some reason, the back of his neck prickled. The very dust and silence in here seemed to tingle with some secret magic.” Spooky. Also, I don’t care who played him in the movie, I’ve always pictured Ollivander as Joel Grey, specifically when he guest-starred on Buffy.

Harry gets time number two where he is told he has his mother’s eyes. He also learns that his mother’s wand was willow and swishy, his father’s was mahogany and pliable and Voldemort’s was yew and powerful. There’s a whole essay to be written (and I’m sure somewhere someone has) about the characteristics of wands and what it says about the owners, but I will not write it here. Harry ends up with a supple, holly wand (my wand is holly with an ebony handle and a dragon heartstring core, in case anybody was wondering. I let the wand choose me, just like in the books). Harry also learns that the core of his wand is a phoenix feather. The bird that gave it gave only one other feather. And the wand it resides in………is Voldemort’s.

DUN DUN DUN! Well, the chapter actually ends with Harry getting his train ticket and being told the train leaves on August 31st from Kings Cross, but that isn’t nearly as dramatic. Tune in tomorrow for chapters 6-11, same bat time, same bat channel. Also, my apologies that this isn’t fraught with adventure and humor. The first half of Sorcerer’s Stone is pretty exposition heavy. I’ll try to do better for you, fair readers.

Comments»

1. larry burns - Monday, June 4, 2007

i can;t beleive i read that all despite having read each of teh books at least 10 times.

2. ladyandrea - Monday, June 4, 2007

Yeah, it’s mostly to spark some discussion and also for people who need refreshers but don’t have time to reread the books.

This is totally in its infant stages, maybe the format will have to be different. We’ll see how it goes.

3. Radioman - Monday, June 4, 2007

You know, I have not read this series, but I might pick it up now that the (alleged) last book is coming out. I hate reading and then waiting, reading then waiting. Thanks for the inspiration Andrea!

4. goathair - Monday, June 4, 2007

I have a feeling that these 5 chapters will end up being the most important in all seven books.

5. ladyandrea - Monday, June 4, 2007

Are you having a go at how kind of boring they are? Cause yeah, it doesn’t really pick up til they get to Diagon Alley, in my opinion.

6. goathair - Monday, June 4, 2007

I’m totally serious. Not necessarily what happens, but I think the things that are said in an off-hand manner will eventually be very important to the mythology of the series. Most notably the connection between Harry and his mother.

7. ladyandrea - Monday, June 4, 2007

I agree, I think off-hand comments throughout the series will come to a head in book 7.

8. goathair - Monday, June 4, 2007

How did you figure out what wand you would get?

9. The Fan's Attic - Monday, June 4, 2007

The one thing I don’t know if I will ever get (maybe it will be resolved in the last book) is how awful the Dursleys are to Harry. I could at least understand it if they were complete asswipes to their own son. To do it to their orphaned nephew seems beyond the pale.

The only explanation I can think of is that Rowling is using the Dursleys as a metaphor for people intolerant of different people/ideas that diverge from their own in a very hamhanded, simplistic manner.

10. Hail Leroy - Monday, June 4, 2007

When you are looking at a series of 7 books (and I think she was even at this point, right?) You’re going to need an awful lot of foundation to build the story on. I don’t think JKR decided to do what Tolkien did and spend 50 years building a mythology and just happen to drop LoTR towards the end of the time line, but there is a fair amount of background that starts taking place here.

I almost wish I hadn’t seen the movies when I re-read these though, because I really cant form mental images of anyone anymore (other than the actors playing them)

11. ladyandrea - Monday, June 4, 2007

Goathair, there’s an option through the HP merchandising where you just get a random wand, so I let mine come to me instead of choosing one for myself.

Fan’s Attic, I think you’re exactly right. I think their intolerance towards magic and being “different” is why they treated Harry so poorly.

Leroy, she didn’t have every little detail down right from the get-go, but from interviews I’ve read, she did have the big stuff fairly well planned out.

My mental pictures tend to be hybrids of my imagination and the actors, unless I just REALLY liked who they cast. Like, McGonagall will always be Maggie Smith in my mind and that’s okay with me. Snape, on the other hand, well — Alan Rickman is too old to play Snape, so I kind of hear Alan Rickman’s voice but imagine someone much younger.

12. Hail Leroy - Monday, June 4, 2007

TFA/LA – I agree on the Dursley’s, but (trying to avoid any spoliers here) I think there is more to it that you suggest and we are going to see something in DH that has been hinted at in HBP

13. Elric VIII Emperor of Melnibone - Monday, June 4, 2007

TFA – Not having read the books in a little while (but this gives me a chance to catch up), I don’t remember for sure, but Rowling does try to flesh out the Dursley’s a little (no pun intended) in Books 5 and 6. I think it was a necessary move too, because one of my criticisms of her is that some of her characters are one dimensional, flat-footed attempts at metaphors.
As for movie characters, I agree with Maggie Smith. I’d add Gary Oldman too, although that might just be my man-love for Gary Oldman.

Oh, and nice Hedburg/Potter crossover, Andie.

14. Elric VIII Emperor of Melnibone - Monday, June 4, 2007

Also, Andie, in response to the Hagrid “there wasn’t one wizard who went bad who didn’t come from Slytherin” quote, I agree with “boo JK Rowling,” I suspect for very similar reasons to you, and I can’t wait to have that discussion.

15. ladyandrea - Monday, June 4, 2007

No, I agree Leroy, we’ll get more in DH.

Elric, I also love Gary Oldman, but again, he’s far too old to play Sirius. I love that they got big name British actors for the movies, but Snape, Lupin, Sirius, Pettigrew, etc etc, are all too old.

In Prisoner of Azkaban, for example, all those characters were 32 or 33 years old, yet the actors were 41 (Lupin), 46 (Sirius), 47 (Pettigrew), and 57 (Snape). That bugs me.

16. Elric VIII Emperor of Melnibone - Monday, June 4, 2007

Andie – I think you have a good point there, and I never really though of it that way, although I’ll try to excuse Oldman/Sirius because a dozen years in Azkaban will do that to you.

And despite my criticism of Rowling, I think I’ll be commenting a lot in this series of columns. Might have to pull out my Quidditch robes at some point (seriously).

17. goathair - Monday, June 4, 2007

At least the actors in the movies all look like they could have went to school together, so that’s consistent.

As for the Dursley’s treating Harry badly, I also think there is going to be some very big reason (which definitely was hinted at Elric) why that family is so intolerant of magic.

18. larry burns - Monday, June 4, 2007

i agree that seems like a very harry potter thing to do to have something mentioned off hand in one of the broing sequences and then ahve it be the most important thing in the books.

once we get to book six i can give examples but till then scared to spoil

19. The Fan's Attic - Monday, June 4, 2007

Elric/LA/Goathair:

I agree, there will be more to the story on the Dursleys in DH. I am re-reading the books now so I am going to have to keep an eye on the Dursley information. It sounds like we all have similar criticisms about her metaphors and simplicity. But, I always have to remind myself that these are intended to be children/young teenager books and the depth may be lost at times.

By the way, excellent idea on this stuff. I can’t wait to talk nerdy Harry Potter stuff with everybody. I’ve never done that before.

20. goathair - Monday, June 4, 2007

I know we’re not supposed to spoil anything, but Harry getting decapitated by the Hogwarts Express in Chapter 6 really surprised me.

21. larry burns - Monday, June 4, 2007

my wand is 10 inches (high schooler stops now)

supple oak with a mahogany handle and the a piece of a unicorns horn inside.

22. Hail Leroy - Monday, June 4, 2007

Just for the record, when I get my copy of SS/PS out to start reading it tonight, the wife is going to refer to me as a loser.

Dont care though

23. Man with No Name - Monday, June 4, 2007

Diagon Alley = Diagonally; Clever play on words there JKR!

Also, my friend Matt, Ph.D. teaches a class rhetorically analyzing the series. Sheer brilliance.

24. ladyandrea - Monday, June 4, 2007

If I was anywhere near a school that had a Harry Potter class, I’d be there every day, even if I just sat in. I did that this year with a Buffy class.

25. The Fan's Attic - Monday, June 4, 2007

I just pre-ordered DH on Amazon. I can’t wait.

26. Slothrop - Monday, June 4, 2007

I taught PS/SS four years ago in a film and lit class and then PoA in a grad seminar on contemporary narratives. They went ok–the Azkaban night was the better of the two.

I am going to agree with the point about the first few chapters being amazing in what they set up–look at the introduction of Sirius. He’s one of the most important characters in the series, yet here he is in a seeming throw away line: “‘Young Sirius Black lent it me…” that’s it for two books. JKR’s planning and organization of a seven book series from the beginning has been amazing.

My other favorite moment early on, Harry realizing that he, Hagrid, and every other witch and wizard simply see the world differently from other people: “[the Muggles’] eyes slid from the big book shop on one side to the record shop on the other as if they couldn’t see the Leaky Cauldron at all” (PS 54).

I love how JKR sets up the rules of the WW in moments like these–I published an essay on visual elements and the WW I can upload if anyone wants to read it.

27. The Fan's Attic - Monday, June 4, 2007

Slothrop…link that shit up.

28. Slothrop - Monday, June 4, 2007

Sure–any suggestions how/where? I can upload it via ftp or something, but I don’t have a website of my own (shocking, I know).

29. goathair - Monday, June 4, 2007

We need to see this essay. We can find a way to get it on the internets.

30. The Fan's Attic - Monday, June 4, 2007

hmm…i assumed you might have a link…i guess i just made an ass out of u and me. i’m not a techy sort of guy. so, i don’t know how to advise you. maybe somebody else can help you. perhaps just create your own blog for this purpose?

31. Slothrop - Monday, June 4, 2007

I just have the word file–the link to the book is here: http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0773460101/ref=wl_it_dp/105-6435477-5316446?ie=UTF8&coliid=I337S3KCXVTDWZ&colid=2LF8TY1Q40SJ1

not that that helps much; I’d put it in a message, but it’s about 20 pages double-spaced.

or, if you send me a request, I will email it:

32. Slothrop - Monday, June 4, 2007

my email is jon (dot) lewis (at) adelphia (dot) net

33. Ivan - Monday, June 4, 2007

Ok…this is going to be awesome.

First: slothrop, if you wouldn’t mind sending a copy to me also, i need something good to read. email: arguello(dot)ivan(at)gmail(dot)com.

Second: The actors have been on and off with me. Maggie Smith was perfect because i had an AP history teacher that was exactly like McGonagall and she also reminds me of Maggie Smith, so it works out. Gary Oldman and Snape bothered me because she always mentions how Sirius was a really good looking guy, and im sorry but i dont share Elric’s man crush on Gary. And Snape because in those little chapter illustration he always has a bit more of an oriental/arab look about him, and i dont know if im putting too much stock in those pictures but i would like someone that looked more like that, Rickman’s voice is spot on though. And i liked Lupid and Pettigrew they both seem to fit for me.
Third: LA there is a teacher that uses PS/SS as one of her books in this honors seminar, but you can’t really get in, its assigned to you and since its a small class they’re bitchy about letting you sit in. I would love to go, but alas…
Fourth: I agree with the interpretation that the Dursley’s mistreatment of Harry has to do with their intolerance of anything they believe to be different then the norm, especially when you take JKR’s stand on those issues in her real life.
Fifth: Yeah the throw-away’s are going to be big, she’s made a habit of that. It has already, which i’m sure we’ll cover later.

And again, just to make it clear, LA you are the awesome-est blogger in the mighty internets for doing this. Its alot of work and it really cool of you to do so. Many Thanks.

34. ladyandrea - Monday, June 4, 2007

Wow, thanks, Ivan. I hope this is a success.

35. Suss-- - Tuesday, June 5, 2007

Did you get to the part yet where Snape kills *********NO CARRIER***********

36. Susan Hated Literature » Blog Archive » Links - Tuesday, June 5, 2007

[…] If you are thinking of rereading the Harry Potter books before the last book[3] comes out you might want to check out DeadOn […]


Leave a comment